What do we mean when we talk about sin taxes?
Somehow, many of the things that we most enjoy, whether that is sugary treats, alcohol, tobacco, or gambling, are classed as ‘sinful’. Sometimes they are sinful because they are bad for all of us, full stop (as in the case of tobacco), sometimes because they are bad for us in excess (sugar and alcohol), and others because they can be a problem for a small minority of people (as in the case of gambling). Are they sinful because they are enjoyable or sinful because they cause us harm?
A great way to raise levies without raising income tax
Whatever the reason for classifying them as sinful, governments around the world find them useful targets for taxation. In some cases, it is hoped that taxing them will raise the price to such a point that people will stop buying them, but generally, and particularly with alcohol and gambling, taxes and levies are regarded as a good and fair source of income. This is very much the case when purse strings are tight and federal coffers need a cash injection. In return for paying a little bit more, consumers are guaranteed a regulated product, and vendors have to operate within strict guidelines.
For example, when buying alcohol, everyone knows that a fair chunk of the price paid is in duties; however, the consumer also knows the alcoholic content of the drink in question. One of the arguments for regulating recreational drugs has always been about making sure that people know how strong the substances are and what they contain. However, New Zealanders decided that cannabis was far too sinful when there was a referendum about its legalisation a few years back.
Targeted taxation for specific purposes
So-called sin taxes can be applied in various ways, and the proceeds can either be used to fund general taxation or to grow a particular sport or cultural activity. Many people feel more positive about this approach to taxing past-time pleasures. This is the model behind the country’s beloved pokies, with at least 40% of revenue generated from pokie machines and not returned to the players, going towards community initiatives in the form of grants.
However, online pokie playing in New Zealand is currently unregulated, and the country does not benefit from any of the millions gambled each year. Currently, the authorities are in the process of creating a regulatory framework for a legal online gambling market, and it is expected to launch in 2026. Even a tiny slice of the millions of dollars expected to be generated in Gross Gambling Revenue could go a long way to fund grassroots rugby in the country. With the country’s Department of Internal Affairs (DIA) issuing a call for online gambling operators to register their interest ahead of time, it would be a good time to test out how online gambling-specific sin taxes and license fees could be diverted to specific causes.
The rush to regulation
Reportedly, several leading brands have expressed an interest in operating in the country once the market opens. 888, Betway, and Bet365 all stated that they would be keen on securing a licence. With revenue in the industry estimated to reach around US$3.11 billion this year and around 40% of New Zealanders enjoying a flutter, it is hardly surprising that the commercial players are keen to get a foothold in the market. Whatever people want to play, whether laying a stake on a sports bet or playing online casino games, there will likely be every choice available from minimum deposit casinos to high-stakes poker games, live dealer games, and sports accumulators. Just as they do now, the review companies like Casino.org will keep players safe by ranking and rating the operators.
Taxation versus commercialisation
Whether the sin taxes and levies will be used to grow rugby remains to be seen. Many would argue that New Zealand are hardly short of fame, cash or commercial opportunities, so why is further investment needed? However, money at the top of any professional sport rarely trickles down to the bottom.
It could be tempting for the government to use the money raised to bolster the general economy, build infrastructure, and support creaking services. This is why so many sports, including rugby, turn to commercial sponsorship instead. Ironically, they are then sponsored by the ‘sinful brands’ like betting platforms, sugary drinks, fast foods, alcoholic beverages, and gambling partners. The line does get drawn at tobacco these days, but in the past, tobacco sponsorship was pretty standard, particularly in motorsports.
Case study – UK National Lottery
There are examples of gambling money being successfully used to fund good causes, particularly in sports. One country which has had standout success from this is the UK, where its National Lottery has funded huge swathes of infrastructure, grassroots and professional sports, as well as arts and cultural events, organisations and festivals. If you watched the Paralympics and listened to any of the country’s athletes in interviews after medal ceremonies, they all thanked the National Lottery for its support.
Sport England supports sporting good causes with funding from The National Lottery and its vision is that everyone in England, regardless of age, background or ability, feels able to take part in sport or physical activity. Yet too often the people with the most to gain from being active are the least able to take part.”
People buying a lottery ticket in the UK have had a massive impact on Rugby. The country’s teams across the four home nations have all seen the positive effects of money raised over three decades. Back in March 1995, rugby union had not yet turned professional, so every penny of the first-ever grant to Fylde Rugby Club of £137,500 awarded to cover facilities was like ‘manna’ from heaven.
A waiting game
The general feeling is that lotteries and games set up to fund sports are possibly more attractive than ‘sin taxes’, but maybe New Zealand‘s new legislation will bring a breakthrough to help with the development of the game.

